Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Girls 02 Rankings

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Apparently it's ok during tournaments but during OPL league play can players who play up come down on age for some crucial/tough games to help with some on-age wins and then go back and play on their play-up team?

    Comment


      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
      Apparently it's ok during tournaments but during OPL league play can players who play up come down on age for some crucial/tough games to help with some on-age wins and then go back and play on their play-up team?
      I don't see why not. I don't think there is any rule against it as long as you are playing your age.

      Comment


        If that's true, then an elite player could essentially play on two teams (on age and one age up)in their club and help both teams compete. Would help the club with wins and help that player develop but probably hurts the development of others (particularly players whose playing time goes down in order to play the elite player. Pros and cons.

        Comment


          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
          If that's true, then an elite player could essentially play on two teams (on age and one age up)in their club and help both teams compete. Would help the club with wins and help that player develop but probably hurts the development of others (particularly players whose playing time goes down in order to play the elite player. Pros and cons.
          Not to mention burn out and "over - development" of a young player.

          Comment


            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
            Apparently it's ok during tournaments but during OPL league play can players who play up come down on age for some crucial/tough games to help with some on-age wins and then go back and play on their play-up team?
            Yes, but there is rules on how many games a player can play in a weekend. That's where teams can get in trouble if they are over using a player. Of course for coaches to track that its a little tough.

            Basically it comes down to ethics. The player pass has some very good uses and can be a great tool, and I think the majority of teams use it for what its for. However, I know there are teams that abuse it as well.

            What would be best is we have systems we use to enter in the players who register with a club. Now if a coach was forced to load their roster with those players into the system before each game, then the system could track how many games a weekend a certain player plays and make sure they aren't being over used.

            Comment


              Its pretty sad that we are talking about this, instead of talking about the fact that Westside Tied the WA state runner ups from last year and the WA state champs. And ***C Beat the WA state Semi finalist, Runner up, and State champs 3-0.

              We complain all the time about our teams not competing, and we have 2 teams doing very well and we are talking about all this other stuff.

              Comment


                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                Its pretty sad that we are talking about this, instead of talking about the fact that Westside Tied the WA state runner ups from last year and the WA state champs. And ***C Beat the WA state Semi finalist, Runner up, and State champs 3-0.

                We complain all the time about our teams not competing, and we have 2 teams doing very well and we are talking about all this other stuff.
                I was talking about entirely different teams.

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                  I was talking about entirely different teams.
                  Well we are in the Gu11 thread so I guess I assumed u were talking about those teams.

                  Comment


                    Any scores yet from day one of games?

                    Comment


                      Scores are posted. Anyone see the Copa TS vs Thusc Emerald tie game? Thought Copa TS would win by a couple goals... Any insights?

                      Comment


                        I didn't see the thusc game.... But what surprised people the most (not there was anything super surprising today, I know the person previous talked about thusc but they are NWCL so tying another NWCL doesn't seem like a surprise)

                        So whats the biggest surprise to you:

                        1. Thusc tying Copa TS
                        2. Eastside tying VFC
                        3. ***C beating FCP 5-1
                        4. FCSC beating Copa

                        Comment


                          All the results are a bit surprising to me but think the most surprising was VFC tying Eastside. So many folks seemed surprised that VFC was even in the NPL... VFC proved why they are.

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                            All the results are a bit surprising to me but think the most surprising was VFC tying Eastside. So many folks seemed surprised that VFC was even in the NPL... VFC proved why they are.
                            I see this the opposite as that Eastside isn't as strong as the rest of the NWCL teams.

                            Most surprising for me is the Thusc v copa ts score.

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                              I see this the opposite as that Eastside isn't as strong as the rest of the NWCL teams.

                              Most surprising for me is the Thusc v copa ts score.
                              Funny, I don't see your point about Eastside. They played ***C last two games and first went to PK's and today ***C only won by one goal and Eastside was one placing pressure second half.

                              Eastside is developing every game. I would predict by next year if this team stays together they will be ahead of many teams that are beating them now.

                              Comment


                                Clueless comment

                                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                                Scores are posted. Anyone see the Copa TS vs Thusc Emerald tie game? Thought Copa TS would win by a couple goals... Any insights?
                                Copa TS hasn't beat Emerald by more than 1 goal in any game, so not sure why you thought this would be any differen't, or that a tie would be so suprising.

                                Also too many people place too much on the summer tournaments. Teams are dealing with kids being gone and filling those gaps in different ways. Some with kids playing up from B teams and some have kids that are playing up come down. I think the season will show the strengths of the real teams.

                                Comment

                                Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                                Auto-Saved
                                x
                                Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                                x
                                Working...
                                X