Originally posted by Unregistered
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
2019 HS Soccer
Collapse
X
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
New realignment
New 12 team D1 - home and home for each group and one game against the other group (6) for a total of 16. Top 8 make playoffs - not sure if top 4 in each group or just top 8.
Anyone know the bottom teams that are out?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
What you are talking about is just the proposal. Yes, if it does get voted through that's what D1 will look like. However, there are other factors as well. One factor I know of is that the lower divisions will have to agree with their placement for this to happen. What if another team wants to be in D1? Or not in D3? And I also heard there may be a D4 for some teams. Which does make sense for them.
Teams that I heard are out of D1 are:
Prout
EG
Burrillville
Scituate
Lincoln HS
I hear Pilgrim is back up to D1 according to proposal.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostWhat you are talking about is just the proposal. Yes, if it does get voted through that's what D1 will look like. However, there are other factors as well. One factor I know of is that the lower divisions will have to agree with their placement for this to happen. What if another team wants to be in D1? Or not in D3? And I also heard there may be a D4 for some teams. Which does make sense for them.
Teams that I heard are out of D1 are:
Prout
EG
Burrillville
Scituate
Lincoln HS
I hear Pilgrim is back up to D1 according to proposal.
Another team wanting in - lol. I could only think Pilgrim wanting to stay out to make up for what they thought was going to be their title last year. Scituate showed a little flash just to stay in the middle, but way too hard for the bottom 3 to remain competitive in D1.
I doubt the bottom 3 required any arm twisting and Prout/EG have to know it would be better to be winning in D2 than the bottom of D1 at some point. I would also think the bottom in D3 would prefer as well a more competitive situation.
Only wish PCOA would keep it at one game against divisional opponents, end the season a week earlier, and let teams schedule 3-4 rivalry/other non-divisional opponents and/or out of state/private school games.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostIt rarely gets to proposal without behind the scenes maneuvering - this group isn't subject to the open meeting rules.
Another team wanting in - lol. I could only think Pilgrim wanting to stay out to make up for what they thought was going to be their title last year. Scituate showed a little flash just to stay in the middle, but way too hard for the bottom 3 to remain competitive in D1.
I doubt the bottom 3 required any arm twisting and Prout/EG have to know it would be better to be winning in D2 than the bottom of D1 at some point. I would also think the bottom in D3 would prefer as well a more competitive situation.
Only wish PCOA would keep it at one game against divisional opponents, end the season a week earlier, and let teams schedule 3-4 rivalry/other non-divisional opponents and/or out of state/private school games.
I do like the smaller D1 and playing an opponent twice with a crossover match. Also, an 8 team playoff makes sense.
Nice changes by RIIL and RIGSCA.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostRIIL does allow for (3 or 4) games, I believe, for non-divisional out of state opponents that do not count against your record. Most of the games form pre-season schedules for several of the D1 and D2 schools. And what you don't play in preseason you can schedule throughout the season if your schedule allows.
I do like the smaller D1 and playing an opponent twice with a crossover match. Also, an 8 team playoff makes sense.
Nice changes by RIIL and RIGSCA.
16 games plus all the other crap -- too many games..have 11 meaningful games in a shorter season (so playoffs end before November!) and let the top 12 in (so finishing 4 or higher means a bye to quarterfinals). yes, fields are becoming less an issue with more turf but you still with 16-19 games (plus playoffs) always end up with some kids playing 3-4 games in a very short (8-10 days) window.
I get HS is not developmental program - but they are still student-athletes (students first..) - at least cutting back to 12 teams maybe will make it more competitive; not sure how D2 is organized now.
- Quote
Comment
Comment