Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Girls 2008 Thread

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
    I have watched as much 08 as the next guy and I can tell you that Select is NOT at the top of the list. As of right now it is Stars Blue followed by NE Surf. The remaining clubs (select, scorpions, stars white, Nefc GA, Bayside and Aztecs) are all pretty close. This being said, the 08 age group has yet to see much movement to ECNL clubs.
    1. Surf
    2. Select
    3. Stars blue
    4. Nefc

    Comment


      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
      1. Surf
      2. Select
      3. Stars blue
      4. Nefc
      Just came across the accepted team list for the FC Stars Tournament in March and wow Select 08 is playing up an age group. That should end all discussion as to who the #1 GU-13 team is going into the spring. Select should definitely be #1. Basically I read into that as they would destroy every team in GU-13 and need better competition. As far as their loss to Stars Blue in the fall, it doesn't mean anything. Teams can have bad games.

      1. Select GA
      2. NEFC GA
      3. Stars Blue
      4. Surf
      5. Select DPL

      Comment


        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
        Just came across the accepted team list for the FC Stars Tournament in March and wow Select 08 is playing up an age group. That should end all discussion as to who the #1 GU-13 team is going into the spring. Select should definitely be #1. Basically I read into that as they would destroy every team in GU-13 and need better competition. As far as their loss to Stars Blue in the fall, it doesn't mean anything. Teams can have bad games.

        1. Select GA
        2. NEFC GA
        3. Stars Blue
        4. Surf
        5. Select DPL
        This is funny. Well know that this is selects MO. Play up so they don’t risk losing to an 08 team and parents such as this poster can think their team must be good because they chose to play up age group. Not to mention the fact that this team failed to make finals of the last two NEP final fours that were contested.

        Comment


          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
          This is funny. Well know that this is selects MO. Play up so they don’t risk losing to an 08 team and parents such as this poster can think their team must be good because they chose to play up age group. Not to mention the fact that this team failed to make finals of the last two NEP final fours that were contested.
          Anyone who has been around more than 1 minute knows this is true.

          Throw in the fact that Select's 09 team is actually good enough to play up and Select can't have them risk playing each other. Wouldn't look good when the 09s take care of business against the 08s.

          Comment


            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
            Just came across the accepted team list for the FC Stars Tournament in March and wow Select 08 is playing up an age group. That should end all discussion as to who the #1 GU-13 team is going into the spring. Select should definitely be #1. Basically I read into that as they would destroy every team in GU-13 and need better competition. As far as their loss to Stars Blue in the fall, it doesn't mean anything. Teams can have bad games.

            1. Select GA
            2. NEFC GA
            3. Stars Blue
            4. Surf
            5. Select DPL
            surely this is a troll job I hope!? Right? I have a daughter who plays 08 DPL and the select DPL team didn't score more than 2 goals for the entire fall. How did you ever put them #5???? Also, select GA played Aztecs a few times this fall and your #1 team lost to Aztecs and struggled every time they played. Aztecs outplayed "the #1 08 team" every single game. List is terrible!! Select GA #5 and Select DPL ?????? off the list of top 25 08 teams.

            Comment


              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
              Just came across the accepted team list for the FC Stars Tournament in March and wow Select 08 is playing up an age group. That should end all discussion as to who the #1 GU-13 team is going into the spring. Select should definitely be #1. Basically I read into that as they would destroy every team in GU-13 and need better competition. As far as their loss to Stars Blue in the fall, it doesn't mean anything. Teams can have bad games.

              1. Select GA
              2. NEFC GA
              3. Stars Blue
              4. Surf
              5. Select DPL
              again, got soccer is not a perfect way to rank teams, but for U-littles it certainly is a pretty good barometer. So this guy is a troll for sure. What he is saying in his rankings is that Select 08 GA which is ranked around #600 in got soccer rankings is the best U-13 team in Massachusetts?? Doesn't pass the smell test. There are definitely better U-13 teams than Select. Gotta love ts. Say and rank any team you want. lol this ranking is highly trollable though!

              Comment


                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                again, got soccer is not a perfect way to rank teams, but for U-littles it certainly is a pretty good barometer. So this guy is a troll for sure. What he is saying in his rankings is that Select 08 GA which is ranked around #600 in got soccer rankings is the best U-13 team in Massachusetts?? Doesn't pass the smell test. There are definitely better U-13 teams than Select. Gotta love ts. Say and rank any team you want. lol this ranking is highly trollable though!
                Stars Blue parent here. As far as south shore select goes in u-13 they are definitely top 6 without question. #1 seems a bit aggressive-and probably a troll job- but definitely 1 of the 10 best teams going. I'd love to see a spring tournament of 10 of the top U-13 teams. It will never happen, but it would be fun to see how all the 08 teams stack up against each other.

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                  again, got soccer is not a perfect way to rank teams, but for U-littles it certainly is a pretty good barometer. So this guy is a troll for sure. What he is saying in his rankings is that Select 08 GA which is ranked around #600 in got soccer rankings is the best U-13 team in Massachusetts?? Doesn't pass the smell test. There are definitely better U-13 teams than Select. Gotta love ts. Say and rank any team you want. lol this ranking is highly trollable though!
                  not perfect? hahaha... especially suspect in time of covid with lack of tournament points

                  much better rankings here- https://youthsoccerrankings.us/rankings/MA/13/Girls/

                  1 FC STARS ECNL BLUE [9] 32.83
                  2 NEW ENGLAND SURF STATE NAVY [41] 31.66
                  3 RUSH NEW ENGLAND AZTEC DPL [79] 30.91
                  4 SOUTH SHORE SELECT U10 ELITE [97] 30.61
                  5 NEFC GA [111] 30.38

                  And the way to read this is if Stars Blue was to play NEFC you'd expect them to win by about 2.5 goals (32-83 - 30.38). Do better than the expectation your points go up. Do worse and you go down. No magic tournament points needed

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                    Stars Blue parent here. As far as south shore select goes in u-13 they are definitely top 6 without question. #1 seems a bit aggressive-and probably a troll job- but definitely 1 of the 10 best teams going. I'd love to see a spring tournament of 10 of the top U-13 teams. It will never happen, but it would be fun to see how all the 08 teams stack up against each other.
                    From a number 1 ranking being a bit on the aggressive side to top 6 to top 10 all in one post. A couple of more posts and select will be maybe top 50 in MA. Maybe.

                    Sorry, couldn't help myself. But overall agree with the poster's sentiment.

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                      From a number 1 ranking being a bit on the aggressive side to top 6 to top 10 all in one post. A couple of more posts and select will be maybe top 50 in MA. Maybe.

                      Sorry, couldn't help myself. But overall agree with the poster's sentiment.
                      Whether they are 6th or 10th in the state select should be playing their own age division. Are they scared? What other excuse is there for totally running away from U-13? Are they afraid to go 0-3 for the tournament?

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                        Whether they are 6th or 10th in the state select should be playing their own age division. Are they scared? What other excuse is there for totally running away from U-13? Are they afraid to go 0-3 for the tournament?
                        Just running away from the risk of having to play their own 09s.

                        Comment


                          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                          Just running away from the risk of having to play their own 09s.
                          are you saying their 09's could beat their 08's? NO WAY!!!

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                            are you saying their 09's could beat their 08's? NO WAY!!!
                            They certainly would. A handful of 09s are double rostered and now start for both teams. Take those three and put them on their 09 team and it may even be a bloodbath.

                            It's no secret here at Select that the 08s are the black sheep. The club is using smoke and mirrors (double rostering their best 09s, avoiding playing other top 08 teams,etc...) to maintain the illusion that the 08s are still a top team.

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                              They certainly would. A handful of 09s are double rostered and now start for both teams. Take those three and put them on their 09 team and it may even be a bloodbath.

                              It's no secret here at Select that the 08s are the black sheep. The club is using smoke and mirrors (double rostering their best 09s, avoiding playing other top 08 teams,etc...) to maintain the illusion that the 08s are still a top team.
                              So what happens if both teams play at the same time and there is a conflict? Where do the 09’s play if that happens? I would think they play on the 08 team that needs help.

                              Comment


                                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                                So what happens if both teams play at the same time and there is a conflict? Where do the 09’s play if that happens? I would think they play on the 08 team that needs help.
                                the coaches have ability to negotiate playing times for league games. i've seen kids fly off the field from one game to get to the next tho. it's awesome for U12 where there were kids getting limited minutes to have little ringers from U11 taking those minutes all to get the mighty win in NEP premiership league play

                                Comment

                                Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                                Auto-Saved
                                x
                                Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                                x
                                Working...
                                X