Originally posted by Unregistered
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
NEFC u11 coach classless
Collapse
X
-
Unregistered
- Quote
-
Unregistered
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
NEFC u11 coach classless
My daughter plays for NEFC. I was at the game. In my opinion, which i'm sure will get chopped to shreds, here's what happened in the game. NEFC has never played against a younger team. After scoring about 30 seconds into the game, NEFC took SSS to lightly. SSS is a very good team. NEFC is a much bigger team physically. Everytime there was contact, and i'm sorry, but soccer is a contact sport, the NEFC players got called for a foul. I"m not saying all the calls weren't legit, but from the NEFC point of view, if they got within 5 yards of an SSS player, they were called for a foul. The game was great with lots of scoring chances for both teams. I think early on, NEFC was not able to put a bunch of open crossing passes into the net and instead put them over the net. NEFC coaches got frustrated. The first SSS goal was the direct result of one of these questionable foul calls. Right or wrong, the call resulted in the first goal. The problem from where i sit was that the refereee swallowed his whistle when the calls should have gone against SSS. TAke down in the box late in the game, and an obvious hands ball near the box midway thru the second half that stopped an NEFC break stand out in my mind. There were also quite a few tripping/kicking fouls aginst SSS that the ref swallowed his whistle on. The play where Nick eventually got tossed was pretty funny. The NEFC girl WAS offsides. The ref made the right call, but Nick needed to be go by that point in the game and he went. Nick went off on the ref, and was rightly tossed. NEFC was finally able to put one of those crossing passes into the net to take a 2-1 lead with about 5 minutes left. Instead of getting down, the SSS girls played as hard as they could in the last 5 minutes and were able to tie the game. What a gut-check by the SSS girls. Very impressive. After the game, the coaches went at each other. IF you're an SSS parent, the ref did a great job. If you're an NEFC parent, they did not. Either way, both teams played a great game and both teams had their chances to win. From where i sit, this is the first time i have to say that the ref did actually influence the outcome of the game. I asked my daughter after the game about Nick. She said that nobody on the team takes anything personally and she really likes playing for him. To me, Nick is an old-time coach from the days i was in school and played sports. He's young, loud, and gets into the game. Eventually he will learn to focus on the next play and not the last call. The ref has NEVER changed his call based on what a coach has to say. I'd like to have intense games like this every week. For my daughter, she loves the intensity and this is why we play club soccer.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
The girls should also being taught good sportsmanship which includes respecting the ref no matter how questionable the calls. THey may love their coach, he may be a fantastic coach, but he should also be a good role model for the kids at ALL times during a game. We have all been at club games (and town games for that matter) where the ref makes bad calls and ends up influencing the final score. Why not wait until after the game, tell the girls how well they played and let them know that sometimes the ref doesn't make the right calls and what is most important is how the girls played--isn't u11 still a developmental age?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostThe girls should also being taught good sportsmanship which includes respecting the ref no matter how questionable the calls. THey may love their coach, he may be a fantastic coach, but he should also be a good role model for the kids at ALL times during a game. We have all been at club games (and town games for that matter) where the ref makes bad calls and ends up influencing the final score. Why not wait until after the game, tell the girls how well they played and let them know that sometimes the ref doesn't make the right calls and what is most important is how the girls played--isn't u11 still a developmental age?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostThe girls should also being taught good sportsmanship which includes respecting the ref no matter how questionable the calls. THey may love their coach, he may be a fantastic coach, but he should also be a good role model for the kids at ALL times during a game. We have all been at club games (and town games for that matter) where the ref makes bad calls and ends up influencing the final score. Why not wait until after the game, tell the girls how well they played and let them know that sometimes the ref doesn't make the right calls and what is most important is how the girls played--isn't u11 still a developmental age?
Liz L., do you do that? You were tossed out before for much more than this. Stop preaching role-modeling.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostMy daughter plays for NEFC. I was at the game. In my opinion, which i'm sure will get chopped to shreds, here's what happened in the game. NEFC has never played against a younger team. After scoring about 30 seconds into the game, NEFC took SSS to lightly. SSS is a very good team. NEFC is a much bigger team physically. Everytime there was contact, and i'm sorry, but soccer is a contact sport, the NEFC players got called for a foul. I"m not saying all the calls weren't legit, but from the NEFC point of view, if they got within 5 yards of an SSS player, they were called for a foul. The game was great with lots of scoring chances for both teams. I think early on, NEFC was not able to put a bunch of open crossing passes into the net and instead put them over the net. NEFC coaches got frustrated. The first SSS goal was the direct result of one of these questionable foul calls. Right or wrong, the call resulted in the first goal. The problem from where i sit was that the refereee swallowed his whistle when the calls should have gone against SSS. TAke down in the box late in the game, and an obvious hands ball near the box midway thru the second half that stopped an NEFC break stand out in my mind. There were also quite a few tripping/kicking fouls aginst SSS that the ref swallowed his whistle on. The play where Nick eventually got tossed was pretty funny. The NEFC girl WAS offsides. The ref made the right call, but Nick needed to be go by that point in the game and he went. Nick went off on the ref, and was rightly tossed. NEFC was finally able to put one of those crossing passes into the net to take a 2-1 lead with about 5 minutes left. Instead of getting down, the SSS girls played as hard as they could in the last 5 minutes and were able to tie the game. What a gut-check by the SSS girls. Very impressive. After the game, the coaches went at each other. IF you're an SSS parent, the ref did a great job. If you're an NEFC parent, they did not. Either way, both teams played a great game and both teams had their chances to win. From where i sit, this is the first time i have to say that the ref did actually influence the outcome of the game. I asked my daughter after the game about Nick. She said that nobody on the team takes anything personally and she really likes playing for him. To me, Nick is an old-time coach from the days i was in school and played sports. He's young, loud, and gets into the game. Eventually he will learn to focus on the next play and not the last call. The ref has NEVER changed his call based on what a coach has to say. I'd like to have intense games like this every week. For my daughter, she loves the intensity and this is why we play club soccer.
And people wonder why the Maple model is bad for youth soccer. (eyeroll)
We have a "professional" coaching 10 and 11 year old girls who loses it over a U11 game against a team with some 9 year olds in it.
And how old was the referee of this U11 game that the "professional" went off on?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
What is it about the nefc coaching staff, from coaching HS to U11, that you read about them on TS all the time. Used to think that it was a few isolated problems, but now it just seems like problems follow them everywhere.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
So should we not teach life lessons during athletics? What can we take out of this? When things don't go your way it's acceptable to act like a spoiled child. Can't wait till one of his players emulate this great behavior and get tossed from a game. Hey coach things weren't going my way so I had to go. I was also at this game and his "tactics" of acting like a lunatic definitely affected the younger SSS team. If that was his plan to motivate his team and intimidate the other I think it was reprehensible and has no place in youth soccer. Jmo
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostWhat is it about the nefc coaching staff, from coaching HS to U11, that you read about them on TS all the time. Used to think that it was a few isolated problems, but now it just seems like problems follow them everywhere.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostSo should we not teach life lessons during athletics? What can we take out of this? When things don't go your way it's acceptable to act like a spoiled child. Can't wait till one of his players emulate this great behavior and get tossed from a game. Hey coach things weren't going my way so I had to go. I was also at this game and his "tactics" of acting like a lunatic definitely affected the younger SSS team. If that was his plan to motivate his team and intimidate the other I think it was reprehensible and has no place in youth soccer. Jmo
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostWhat a hoot!!!
And people wonder why the Maple model is bad for youth soccer. (eyeroll)
We have a "professional" coaching 10 and 11 year old girls who loses it over a U11 game against a team with some 9 year olds in it.
And how old was the referee of this U11 game that the "professional" went off on?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostWhat is it about the nefc coaching staff, from coaching HS to U11, that you read about them on TS all the time. Used to think that it was a few isolated problems, but now it just seems like problems follow them everywhere.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
A coach should not every lose their cool in front of their players. Players take on the attitude of the coach and will copy what they do during the game. Arguing with the referee is never going to change the outcome of the call and usually will cause them to call the game in favor of the other team. I do not agree with teams playing up for multiple reasons but referees should call the game based on the age group/level of play and not the age of a team playing up. No league should allow teams to play up for developmental reasons. I also think all leagues should have a referee comment form for the coaches to fill out after the game and mail into the referee assignor for those leagues. The assignor needs to assign qualified referees to the appropriate age and level of play. Also any game that has offsides should have a referee and two referee assistants.
I have seen many SSS teams play up in indoors/outdoors and the referees always error on their side of the smaller younger team. I will agree that soccer is a contact sport and physical play is sometimes part of the game. I will also agree with this parent that kids do not play as hard against smaller younger teams for the fear of hurting them. SSS U10 is a very talented team but I think teams should always play age appropriate games even if they are better than their competition.
- Quote
Comment
Comment