Edp trapped player rules. Anything?

[Unregistered]

No different then the players born in Aug-Sept that were a grade up on their team mates before the change. People think that things were different in the before time....well it wasn't. Just the birthdays of those it included.

Find a club/team that plays fall while you wait on those playing in HS. It really isn't that hard. You panty waste snowflakes think that your kid should be playing with their team only and that the club/league owes you that. Morning...Reality....

This is one of the reasons why a change will be made again back to 8/1 cutoff

[Unregistered]

Play

No different then the players born in Aug-Sept that were a grade up on their team mates before the change. People think that things were different in the before time....well it wasn't. Just the birthdays of those it included.

Find a club/team that plays fall while you wait on those playing in HS. It really isn't that hard. You panty waste snowflakes think that your kid should be playing with their team only and that the club/league owes you that. Morning...Reality....

So take a spot of a kid who is actually on the team until your kid decides to move back up to the older team come spring?

Yeah that happens all over/not reality Mr. Reality.

[Unregistered]

So take a spot of a kid who is actually on the team until your kid decides to move back up to the older team come spring?

Yeah that happens all over/not reality Mr. Reality.

So your solution is have the kid not play call? Most teams don’t have fall u15 teams.

[Unregistered]

This is one of the reasons why a change will be made again back to 8/1 cutoff

The main reason is since the move the calendar year the overall youth enrollment has rapidly declined and the who want to play with their classmates cannot and play another sport. This topic will probably come up again over the winter as it has every year now.

[Unregistered]

So take a spot of a kid who is actually on the team until your kid decides to move back up to the older team come spring?

Yeah that happens all over/not reality Mr. Reality.

It does if the older player is allowed to play down, which is allowed in some leagues. Face it, some coaches only care about winning so if the older player is stronger they'll get PT. Needless to say it doesn't go over well with the parents of younger kids. But at the same time it's not the player's fault they were born in the wrong month for USSF

[Unregistered]

It does if the older player is allowed to play down, which is allowed in some leagues. Face it, some coaches only care about winning so if the older player is stronger they'll get PT. Needless to say it doesn't go over well with the parents of younger kids. But at the same time it's not the player's fault they were born in the wrong month for USSF

To me it would be about honestly. If the younger team's coach told the team before the year that there was a chance that some older kids would play over the winter (or whatever time period), and this is the policy, then I would be okay with it. Just be honest about the number, the length of time, if they would be starting or not (they shouldn't be in my opinion), and how much PT they'll be getting (they shouldn't be playing majority of games).

[Unregistered]

So the issue is and always been that this singles out a group of kids who can’t play in the fall for two seasons. The reality is nobody is going pro so the point is to keep the kids active and make the playing field as level as possible. Under Current rules it’s not equitable. Give the few kids hurt by this a chance to play. Most clubs don’t offer u15 fall teams. That’s the reality.

[Unregistered]

To me it would be about honestly. If the younger team's coach told the team before the year that there was a chance that some older kids would play over the winter (or whatever time period), and this is the policy, then I would be okay with it. Just be honest about the number, the length of time, if they would be starting or not (they shouldn't be in my opinion), and how much PT they'll be getting (they shouldn't be playing majority of games).

You're not going to last in club soccer if you expect clubs to be honest.

[Unregistered]

No different then the players born in Aug-Sept that were a grade up on their team mates before the change. People think that things were different in the before time....well it wasn't. Just the birthdays of those it included.

Find a club/team that plays fall while you wait on those playing in HS. It really isn't that hard. You panty waste snowflakes think that your kid should be playing with their team only and that the club/league owes you that. Morning...Reality....

Yes, it is different. If you choose to play up then that is on you. But these kiddos donnot have a choice unlike the other kids. Completely different!

[Unregistered]

No different then the players born in Aug-Sept that were a grade up on their team mates before the change. People think that things were different in the before time....well it wasn't. Just the birthdays of those it included.

Find a club/team that plays fall while you wait on those playing in HS. It really isn't that hard. You panty waste snowflakes think that your kid should be playing with their team only and that the club/league owes you that. Morning...Reality....

If you are a grade-up on your teammates, then there is no issue, because a 9th grader on a team full of 8th graders is able to join their high school team like all 9th graders can, or they can choose to play club in the fall with their 8th grade teammates and skip HS. The issue that trapped players in the current birth-year system is that the trapped 8th grader has nowhere to play at all (they can't play down a year, and they can't play HS).

[Unregistered]

If you are a grade-up on your teammates, then there is no issue, because a 9th grader on a team full of 8th graders is able to join their high school team like all 9th graders can, or they can choose to play club in the fall with their 8th grade teammates and skip HS. The issue that trapped players in the current birth-year system is that the trapped 8th grader has nowhere to play at all (they can't play down a year, and they can't play HS).

Those same trapped 8th graders also are left without teams senior year as most of their teammates will have graduated. The U19 bracket helps but by it's not the same as finishing out with your peers.

[Unregistered]

Those same trapped 8th graders also are left without teams senior year as most of their teammates will have graduated. The U19 bracket helps but by it's not the same as finishing out with your peers.

The bigger issue for those trapped 8th graders is when they get to junior year. Those juniors who are trying to get recruited to play college soccer will be on teams with a bunch of seniors who have already committed and have no motivation to attend spring showcases, so often times those teams can't get enough players together to travel to the bigger showcases. Many of those U18/19 teams skip the spring showcases altogether, and many of the bigger showcases (like PDA Memorial Day Weekend) don't even have a U18 bracket. Some leagues/showcases like ECNL allow those players to play in U17 brackets within their own club, but many others do not.

[Unregistered]

The bigger issue for those trapped 8th graders is when they get to junior year. Those juniors who are trying to get recruited to play college soccer will be on teams with a bunch of seniors who have already committed and have no motivation to attend spring showcases, so often times those teams can't get enough players together to travel to the bigger showcases. Many of those U18/19 teams skip the spring showcases altogether, and many of the bigger showcases (like PDA Memorial Day Weekend) don't even have a U18 bracket. Some leagues/showcases like ECNL allow those players to play in U17 brackets within their own club, but many others do not.

op here and yes that is also a problem. The whole thing needs to be scrapped and returned to 8/1. It hurts a lot of kids and benefits a handful.

[Unregistered]

This thread is nonsense

What is pint?

[Unregistered]

What is pint?

Why is a concern parents have nonsense? Seems like it’s a problem. Don’t like the thread it’s simple don’t click on it hunny.