Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Shall we switch team?

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Shall we switch team?

    My u13 daughter played in premier 4 EDP. She plays attacking mid and striker, and is a solid player in my mind. She plays the whole game or over 90%, and scores one goal a game in the spring and fall EDP league (scores about 60% of the team goals). Her currently team is not a top one and they are average in the bracket. She has beee steadily improving but I see she may hit a plateau. She was thinking to switch to a better team next fall. It may mean less play time, subs, less goals in a more competitive team. Parents with similar experience, sha ll we jump in order for her to get better training and competition?

    #2
    If she wants to play at a higher level than yes.

    Comment


      #3
      Yes if she is looking to play in college. No if she just wants to enjoy the game and play with her friends. But don’t jump to another EDP team. Go to a GA or ECNL team.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by Guest View Post
        Yes if she is looking to play in college. No if she just wants to enjoy the game and play with her friends. But don’t jump to another EDP team. Go to a GA or ECNL team.
        Totally agree with this. Playing with better players will push her and see what’s she made of and if she wants the next level. Good luck.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Guest View Post
          If she wants to play at a higher level than yes.
          Agree with this, not all good players play past HS.

          Comment


            #6
            -what does she want to do? Is she motivated to work hard? Because moving up will mean more competition for PT. Does she want to play in college?

            - winter is an excellent time to request she attend some practices at local clubs that might be a good fit. Both you and the club can assess fit. Don't wait for tryout season, do it Jan/Feb/March.

            Comment


              #7
              and is she good enough to play in a college that you would want her to go to for her studies? If she is s "division 1" student, but a "division 3" soccer player, than no (given she likes the girls on her team)

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Guest View Post
                My u13 daughter played in premier 4 EDP. She plays attacking mid and striker, and is a solid player in my mind. She plays the whole game or over 90%, and scores one goal a game in the spring and fall EDP league (scores about 60% of the team goals). Her currently team is not a top one and they are average in the bracket. She has beee steadily improving but I see she may hit a plateau. She was thinking to switch to a better team next fall. It may mean less play time, subs, less goals in a more competitive team. Parents with similar experience, sha ll we jump in order for her to get better training and competition?
                If you want out of EDP and want to move to a GA or ECNL club you need to realize they are vastly different. The commitment level needs to be at 100%. There is no not going to practice because she wants to hang out with her friends etc. If you are looking to stay in EDP just switch for better training and competition, then start watching the top teams in the spring. You have to also remember at that age everyone is learning 11v11. So if the players on the team are “average” and you don’t think the group as a whole will improve after spring try outs, then likely you’ll need to switch.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Guest View Post
                  My u13 daughter played in premier 4 EDP. She plays attacking mid and striker, and is a solid player in my mind. She plays the whole game or over 90%, and scores one goal a game in the spring and fall EDP league (scores about 60% of the team goals). Her currently team is not a top one and they are average in the bracket. She has beee steadily improving but I see she may hit a plateau. She was thinking to switch to a better team next fall. It may mean less play time, subs, less goals in a more competitive team. Parents with similar experience, sha ll we jump in order for her to get better training and competition?
                  Two years ago, i decided to take my daughter to a better team. She was the best player in her previous team, but i felt that she was not getting better.
                  The transition was hard, it took her 1/2 to get acclimated to her new team. But now she has flourish and is now one of the best players in the team.

                  I hope this is helpful

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Wish my kid had switched teams. Now I just have to pay for garbage and get angry just taking her to games. I support her just not the decision/team she stayed with. Total waste of money and time. Pretty sure mom has her convinced she is much better than she is.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Guest View Post
                      Wish my kid had switched teams. Now I just have to pay for garbage and get angry just taking her to games. I support her just not the decision/team she stayed with. Total waste of money and time. Pretty sure mom has her convinced she is much better than she is.
                      What club?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Guest View Post
                        Wish my kid had switched teams. Now I just have to pay for garbage and get angry just taking her to games. I support her just not the decision/team she stayed with. Total waste of money and time. Pretty sure mom has her convinced she is much better than she is.
                        Talking about matchfit shore aren’t we?!?

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Guest View Post

                          What club?
                          Just a regular EDP team but there are options much closer that are the same level/just as bad a team. No need to commute to practices for no reason when I could drive 5 minutes and drop off instead of driving for 40 and sitting for 1.5 hours and drive another 40.

                          Would also like the practices to not be on back to back Tues/Wed. nights which I think is a total waste. Why not have them both the same night then if doing it for convenience/just to get it over with?

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Guest View Post

                            Just a regular EDP team but there are options much closer that are the same level/just as bad a team. No need to commute to practices for no reason when I could drive 5 minutes and drop off instead of driving for 40 and sitting for 1.5 hours and drive another 40.

                            Would also like the practices to not be on back to back Tues/Wed. nights which I think is a total waste. Why not have them both the same night then if doing it for convenience/just to get it over with?
                            Sounds like you should switch.

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Guest View Post
                              My u13 daughter played in premier 4 EDP. She plays attacking mid and striker, and is a solid player in my mind. She plays the whole game or over 90%, and scores one goal a game in the spring and fall EDP league (scores about 60% of the team goals). Her currently team is not a top one and they are average in the bracket. She has beee steadily improving but I see she may hit a plateau. She was thinking to switch to a better team next fall. It may mean less play time, subs, less goals in a more competitive team. Parents with similar experience, sha ll we jump in order for her to get better training and competition?
                              ? [/QUOTE]

                              Just realize Premier 4 edp is vastly different than tier 1 edp, forget ga and ecnl. That 1 goal a game in tier 4 may not equate well in upper levels. Yes playing and practicing with better players will make her better but adjustment may be a tough one. If you want to see what she's made of, go for it

                              Comment

                              Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                              Auto-Saved
                              x
                              Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                              x
                              Working...
                              X