Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

ECNL wants to switch back to school year from birth year

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    or maybe we have been focused on votes and elections that actually have more say in our lives than this BY vs SY debate

    Comment


      US Soccer statement and link for feedback:
      https://www.ussoccer.com/ecosystem-r...r-registration

      Comment


        Originally posted by Guest View Post
        US Soccer statement and link for feedback:
        https://www.ussoccer.com/ecosystem-r...r-registration
        That’s a formality to make everyone feel like they had a voice

        Comment


          Originally posted by Guest View Post

          That’s a formality to make everyone feel like they had a voice
          Yeah considering there are no actually questions and just an open box for comments. No one's reading those.

          Comment


            Decision's been made.
            Devil's in the details of implementation now.
            Some ECNL clubs have already informed Q4s of which team they will moving to for spring.

            No cuts happening. Only internal movement.

            Comment


              Originally posted by Guest View Post
              Decision's been made.
              Devil's in the details of implementation now.
              Some ECNL clubs have already informed Q4s of which team they will moving to for spring.

              No cuts happening. Only internal movement.
              Very interesting

              Comment


                Will all q4s be evaluated for national team or will NLq4s go to NL and RLq4s go to RL?

                My q4 is a starter on the RL team. Quite sure she would be a starter on the NL team of her grade. I hope she gets a chance to prove herself.

                What about Q4s that are on the bench of the NL team
                Are they just shoo ins for the NL team? That wouldn't be fair to us RL Q4s.
                ​​​​

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Guest View Post
                  Decision's been made.
                  Devil's in the details of implementation now.
                  Some ECNL clubs have already informed Q4s of which team they will moving to for spring.

                  No cuts happening. Only internal movement.
                  Who is Q4? 8/1 or 9/1? August stays with their grade?

                  Comment


                    Cut off dates will be important to specific kids and what team they make or not. In the grand scheme of soccer in the US, the cut off is irrelevant. US Soccer should re-examine their over all approach to identifying and developing top level youth players. Leaving it to for profit clubs and paying for extra sessions is the big picture problem that they need to solve. We are so focused on our individual kids that we accept this broken system. If we all put as much energy into demanding a better system as we have for debating this issue, then we may get a a true development system. However, I doubt that we will put forth the energy. The rest of the world will pass our women’s programs and both sexes will be irrelevant globally with 10 years.

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Guest View Post
                      Will all q4s be evaluated for national team or will NLq4s go to NL and RLq4s go to RL?

                      My q4 is a starter on the RL team. Quite sure she would be a starter on the NL team of her grade. I hope she gets a chance to prove herself.

                      What about Q4s that are on the bench of the NL team
                      Are they just shoo ins for the NL team? That wouldn't be fair to us RL Q4s.
                      ​​​​
                      Why would you expect anyone on here to know the answers to any of those questions?

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by Guest View Post
                        Will all q4s be evaluated for national team or will NLq4s go to NL and RLq4s go to RL?

                        My q4 is a starter on the RL team. Quite sure she would be a starter on the NL team of her grade. I hope she gets a chance to prove herself.

                        What about Q4s that are on the bench of the NL team
                        Are they just shoo ins for the NL team? That wouldn't be fair to us RL Q4s.
                        ​​​​
                        NL Q4s will be shoo ins.
                        RL Q4s will be evaluated

                        Comment


                          Originally posted by Guest View Post
                          Decision's been made.
                          Devil's in the details of implementation now.
                          Some ECNL clubs have already informed Q4s of which team they will moving to for spring.

                          No cuts happening. Only internal movement.
                          Which ECNL clubs have done this?

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Guest View Post

                            NL Q4s will be shoo ins.
                            RL Q4s will be evaluated
                            I don’t think all NL Q4s are shoo ins. 2010 Stars Blue has like 7 trapped players. Not all of them are shoo ins to make Blue National 2011. Unless Stars keeps 25 kids on the roster.

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Guest View Post

                              NL Q4s will be shoo ins.
                              RL Q4s will be evaluated
                              At our ECNL club all Q4s (national and regional) are being evaluated. Starters are most likely shoo ins for the Natl team. One of them will most likely stay on our team.

                              There are some good q4 players on the regional team that if added to our team will increase our place on the leaderboard. We have some q1s on our team that didn't belong. They should be replaced by the Q4s.

                              ​​​​​​

                              Comment


                                Originally posted by Guest View Post

                                I don’t think all NL Q4s are shoo ins. 2010 Stars Blue has like 7 trapped players. Not all of them are shoo ins to make Blue National 2011. Unless Stars keeps 25 kids on the roster.
                                Roster maximum is 30. So yes they can have 25.

                                Comment

                                Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                                Auto-Saved
                                x
                                Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                                x
                                Working...
                                X