Comparing GA, ECNL and ECRL

[Guest]

Current overall GA Record: NEFC 64W-10L-12D, SSS 53W-19L-12D. ECNL: Stars Blue 56W-12L-8D, Stars White 15W-52L-8D, Scorpions 29W-37L-17D

[Guest]

Current overall GA Record: NEFC 64W-10L-12D, SSS 53W-19L-12D. ECNL: Stars Blue 56W-12L-8D, Stars White 15W-52L-8D, Scorpions 29W-37L-17D

^^^ uLittle parent who cares about wins and losses...

[Guest]

Current overall GA Record: NEFC 64W-10L-12D, SSS 53W-19L-12D. ECNL: Stars Blue 56W-12L-8D, Stars White 15W-52L-8D, Scorpions 29W-37L-17D

I appreciate the effort you put into this, but can you explain how it is in any way meaningful?

[Guest]

I appreciate the effort you put into this, but can you explain how it is in any way meaningful?

My kids baseball has a better winning percentage than the Red Sox. My kids team must be better

[Guest]

My kid is almost done with this and committed to a good D1 school (not P4) that wont cost us a ton. So no real horse. I would really strongly advise anyone with a kid playing and looking at college to see if they're good enough to play for Stars Blue at 50%+. I'd say the same if i was in NY and my kid had WC as an option or NJ with PDA close enough. If so, you go. These are the top places to play in their areas. If not, you have to make some decisions.

GA for 07s and older has been a decent option but for kids younger, i think its going to get tough. ECNL is finally making the consolidation moves it should have (from a business pov) back in 2021. I still think Stars having two teams is a bit much but NEFC having two in GA is beyond nuts.

[Guest]

This is actually a pretty well crafted troll. It may not be obvious to all what rubbish it is.

My kid is almost done with this and committed to a good D1 school (not P4) that wont cost us a ton. So no real horse.

Always a tell that there is an axe to grind.

I would really strongly advise anyone with a kid playing and looking at college to see if they're good enough to play for Stars Blue at 50%+. I'd say the same if i was in NY and my kid had WC as an option or NJ with PDA close enough. If so, you go. These are the top places to play in their areas.

Wow, that’s deep wisdom, hard earned knowledge from years of experience.

In other words, that couldn’t be more obvious.

If not, you have to make some decisions.

This is where 99%+ of the players are and where it gets interesting. Guess your decade in club soccer leaves you with …. Nothing useful to add to the discussion.

GA for 07s and older has been a decent option but for kids younger, i think it’s going to get tough. ECNL is finally making the consolidation moves it should have (from a business pov) back in 2021. I still think Stars having two teams is a bit much but NEFC having two in GA is beyond nuts.

Here’s where you make it obvious. Stars has 2 teams in a location that’s an extreme commute for most players. And an explicit policy that to make one team the best, they will make the other team a permanent cellar dweller.

NEFC has two very different geographies, both far more accessible and large enough to support a strong team. Each team stands in its own. A completely different dynamic.

[Guest]

This is actually a pretty well crafted troll. It may not be obvious to all what rubbish it is.Always a tell that there is an axe to grind.

Wow, that’s deep wisdom, hard earned knowledge from years of experience.

In other words, that couldn’t be more obvious.

This is where 99%+ of the players are and where it gets interesting. Guess your decade in club soccer leaves you with …. Nothing useful to add to the discussion.

Here’s where you make it obvious. Stars has 2 teams in a location that’s an extreme commute for most players. And an explicit policy that to make one team the best, they will make the other team a permanent cellar dweller.

NEFC has two very different geographies, both far more accessible and large enough to support a strong team. Each team stands in its own. A completely different dynamic.

Agree. NEFC red and navy will both be competitive.

Why does white and blue practice in same location? They could field two strong teams if they were spread out. Instead that have a great team and a meh team. White only exists to play the Blue bills. Don't be a sucker. Don't accept any white offer.

[Guest]

NEFC Red will be the top team but that navy sales pitch is crap. NEFC will not accept diluting Red and missing nationals. If it does a lot of loyal families will leave.

[Guest]

NEFC Red will be the top team but that navy sales pitch is crap. NEFC will not accept diluting Red and missing nationals. If it does a lot of loyal families will leave.

You are missing the whole point. They don’t need to dilute Red. There’s no significant competition or overlap between Mendon and the North Shore.

[Guest]

We want the best talent across NEFC to be at Red. We don’t want them staying in the north shore. That is the point.

[Guest]

We want the best talent across NEFC to be at Red. We don’t want them staying in the north shore. That is the point.

Ok fake NEFC parent.

[Guest]

DPL level players moving up to GA teams. Ri Surf and Bayside teams are weak. ECNL and ECRL will just get stronger over time as GA falls apart

[Guest]

The thread is called Comparing GA, ECNL, ECRL
EASY based on leagues not teams
#1: ECNL
#2: GA
#3: ECRL 1
#4: DPL
#5: ECRL2

are there better players on the ECRL teams than the GA teams yes.
But if we are comparing leagues this is it.

[Guest]

The thread is called Comparing GA, ECNL, ECRL
EASY based on leagues not teams
#1: ECNL
#2: GA
#3: ECRL 1
#4: DPL
#5: ECRL2

are there better players on the ECRL teams than the GA teams yes.
But if we are comparing leagues this is it.

This is accurate

[Guest]

How much longer does GA last? Will ECRL replace GA?