So what's the consensus on HS soccer in PA? Daughter is starting HS this year, coming from an ECNL club she was shocked at the lax attitude of the older players at the first few practices (most are town team players). Said the coach was pretty good though. I'm sure things are very good at Pennridge, Stoga, etc. but what is the level of play for the teams outside of the top 10-15 programs? Is it more social than competitive? Squeezing 18 or so games into a 9 week season seems like a recipe for injuries. Do most teams carry a big bench?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
HS Soccer in PA
Collapse
X
-
UnregisteredTags: None
- Quote
-
Unregistered
My daughter played ECNL and high school soccer. Her high school team was terrible but she was in it for the social aspect and enjoyed it, though it was terrible soccer. She was also a team captain and it really gave her some leadership experience as well. So it really didn’t develop her game, but she developed more as a person and is now playing in college. You have to balance that with injuries. These girls could play 3-4 per week and injury rate is high. My daughter got knocked out by injuries in 2 of her 4 high school seasons,which also caused her to miss playing time with her club, and it did set her game game back during the recruiting years. That being said, She still achieved her goal to play in college and she wouldn’t have traded the experience. A lot of these girls play for the fun of it and was a nice break for the seriousness and ultra competiveness of ECNL. Each kid is different and has to weigh the options that are best for them.
- Quote
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostMy daughter played ECNL and high school soccer. Her high school team was terrible but she was in it for the social aspect and enjoyed it, though it was terrible soccer. She was also a team captain and it really gave her some leadership experience as well. So it really didn’t develop her game, but she developed more as a person and is now playing in college. You have to balance that with injuries. These girls could play 3-4 per week and injury rate is high. My daughter got knocked out by injuries in 2 of her 4 high school seasons,which also caused her to miss playing time with her club, and it did set her game game back during the recruiting years. That being said, She still achieved her goal to play in college and she wouldn’t have traded the experience. A lot of these girls play for the fun of it and was a nice break for the seriousness and ultra competiveness of ECNL. Each kid is different and has to weigh the options that are best for them.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostSo what's the consensus on HS soccer in PA? Daughter is starting HS this year, coming from an ECNL club she was shocked at the lax attitude of the older players at the first few practices (most are town team players). Said the coach was pretty good though. I'm sure things are very good at Pennridge, Stoga, etc. but what is the level of play for the teams outside of the top 10-15 programs? Is it more social than competitive? Squeezing 18 or so games into a 9 week season seems like a recipe for injuries. Do most teams carry a big bench?
Be careful, the next time you blink it will be over.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostListen, if you want to thumb your nose for whatever reason at whichever league, have at it ... plenty of reasons to crucify HS, ECNL, GA, MLSn, ECRL, EDP, NPL ..... and most do. If your kid simply loves the game, it is a chance for her to play 5 or 6 days a week. Will it be Barcelona training? Nope ... and neither is ECNL ... but you aren't scoffing at that. As I told my kids, everything you do is what you make it or allow it to be. Tell your kid to chill and take it all in freshman year and then try her best to be her best .... every single day. For whatever it is worth, your 14 year old likely has not played against 17-19 year olds for long, ever. Now she has a chance to. And while some struggle with the game, many are simply bigger, faster, and tougher than her. Likely better and smarter too. If you let her sit back and complain, make her quit now as it is a long 4 years. My kids (boy and 2 girls) also play in high level leagues and still love HS soccer where they can do far more than they normally do on their club teams and they are all molding into leaders on and off the field. My advice to you is not to worry about all of the stuff you can not control like # of games and size of the bench. She just needs to be one of the 11 starters and then the bench size is unimportant. PS - ECNL squishes most of their games into a short spring season too ... add in some tournaments in there and it is not far different than HS. GA/GDA/MLSn often spread their games out, but, in my experience, scrimmage quite a bit in practice and still pick up some friendlies. Lots of play there too ... its the only way for kids to improve .... and, yes, some get hurt. Enjoy the ride it ends quickly and playing night games (especially friday night games) in front of all of your friends and classmates never gets old and HS rivalries are unparalleled ... one of the last places kids get to exhibit and work their local pride over common, local opponents.
Be careful, the next time you blink it will be over.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
If your kid plays in one of the higher classifications, HS soccer is well worth playing. The idea that club soccer is so much better than HS soccer is an absolute farce. The officiating in club is better, which leads to a slightly cleaner game, but it's the same boot and chase style that is so prevalent in the ECNL/GAL on down.
Most club players love HS soccer because it's pressure-free fun.
I've had several kids go through HS soccer and met many parents who thought their kids were too good for it. I can say without hesitation, they were not. Good players, yes. Dominant? Not even close.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostIf your kid plays in one of the higher classifications, HS soccer is well worth playing. The idea that club soccer is so much better than HS soccer is an absolute farce. The officiating in club is better, which leads to a slightly cleaner game, but it's the same boot and chase style that is so prevalent in the ECNL/GAL on down.
Most club players love HS soccer because it's pressure-free fun.
I've had several kids go through HS soccer and met many parents who thought their kids were too good for it. I can say without hesitation, they were not. Good players, yes. Dominant? Not even close.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
HS Soccer in PA
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostHahahaha. What an overreaching and pompus statement about those that donot choose hs soccer. Like picking leagues to olay, the choice to play hs or not is personal.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Comment