Are new ECRL teams playing against other new ECRL teams (eg. Manhattan Soccer Club vs NY Surf vs SUSA 'C" team) or will these new ECRL teams be also playing against established ECRL teams - like "B" teams of SUSA, EMSC and WCFC?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Are new ECRL teams truly "ECRL"?
Collapse
X
-
GuestTags: None
- Quote
-
Guest
Their league play will be against other new ECRL teams. Whether or not there will be any crossover games with the other ECRL leagues in our area is TBD.
- Quote
-
Guest
I've heard the opposite - it's all combined but split into North and South groups of 10 each and a few cross over games between North and South. So in general a lot less travel, worse competition
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View PostI've heard the opposite - it's all combined but split into North and South groups of 10 each and a few cross over games between North and South. So in general a lot less travel, worse competition
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
How is that the opposite? Has nothing to do with the existing ECRL league (New England) where SUSA/EMSC/WCFC "B" teams currently play.
Wouldn't it have been a good idea for them to clarify all of this in their announcement?
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
No they combine old + new and split into North and South.
Wouldn't it have been a good idea for them to clarify all of this in their announcement?
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
My understanding is that this is simply a new Northeast conference. The new conference may split into North and South and cross-over among it, but the existing ECRL New England and North Atlantic conferences remain as is with the ECNL clubs.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
Seems that's too much to ask for
The 20 clubs are in their own Northeast "Regional League" -- as an expansion to the existing "Regional Leagues", which includes New England and North Atlantic. Think of each "Regional League" as a conference.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
It's compeltely clear in their press release: https://www.ecnlgirls.com/2023/04/04...gional-league/
The 20 clubs are in their own Northeast "Regional League" -- as an expansion to the existing "Regional Leagues", which includes New England and North Atlantic. Think of each "Regional League" as a conference.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
Agree, it's pretty clear that the "Northeast" league is separate from New England and North Atlantic. But 20 teams in a single league seems a bit much, so there is some question regarding whether or not they will split Northeast into North and South (it would make more sense for them to do that so that the travel isn't so far).
But the important thing from the original post is that yes, you aren't playing against any New England or North Atlantic ECNL clubs for regular league games, but probably will be matched against some other ECNL/RL teams in the showcases.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
No, they plucked out 20 additional clubs that werent already in ECNL, GA, E64, DPL .... (in some cases clubs with multiple higher level teams in those leagues) ... i am sure there were plenty of really tippety-top, super-talented, quality teams left that are as good or better than most of the teams in the leagues above them ..... shamefully, many of the ECRL2teams will be able to compete with and consistently beat the sham teams that litter ECNL's first C league (ECRL1).
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Sounds like Northeast is parallel to New England.
If a club has three teams, they can put A in ECNL, B in ECRL New England and C in ECRL Northeast.
If a club has two teams, its A in ECNL and B in ECNL New England (basically staying unchanged)
If a club is just joining as a new participant, its A team is ECRL Northeast
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View PostSounds like Northeast is parallel to New England.
If a club has three teams, they can put A in ECNL, B in ECRL New England and C in ECRL Northeast.
If a club has two teams, its A in ECNL and B in ECNL New England (basically staying unchanged)
If a club is just joining as a new participant, its A team is ECRL Northeast
There is variability in every ECNL conference and ECRL conference, but I would venture to say that ECRL Northeast will have the largest gap between best and worst with ECRL Northeast's worst being below ECRL New England's worst.
Does that make it a bad choice? No, it depends on the usual factors: distance to club, cost, coach/trainer, place on team, playing time, practice schedules, game travel requirements, etc.
All of these discussions are irrelevant if you aren't trying to play in college. If you are, then you want to be on the best team where you will be playing regularly. Players are going to get more attention from college coaches if they are on an ECNL team than ECRL, regardless of playing time.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Comment