Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2012 girls

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by Guest View Post

    Or FA or NJP in most age groups are better than pda white and south.
    Most? Lol stop ir. Maybe younger like 2015-2012. Stops there.

    Comment


      Originally posted by Guest View Post

      Most? Lol stop ir. Maybe younger like 2015-2012. Stops there.
      It wouldn’t stop there if they were in one of those leagues. The reason why clubs fall apart after u13 is because everyone thinks they need to be in ECNL, RL, GA. If those younger teams are better and they had a league to play in.. they wouldn’t be losing players.

      Comment


        Originally posted by Guest View Post
        There is PLENTY of talent.
        No there isn't. That is the issue. most of the clubs mentioned have one or two quality girls (sans FA) at my daughter's age group and the vast majority of players are not ECNL quality. The fact that South and white are weak points to the issue of not enough talent.

        Comment


          Originally posted by Guest View Post

          No there isn't. That is the issue. most of the clubs mentioned have one or two quality girls (sans FA) at my daughter's age group and the vast majority of players are not ECNL quality. The fact that South and white are weak points to the issue of not enough talent.
          PDA south lost to SJEB 2-0, MFA 3-2, and PDA Blue 3-0. Those are not bad games, just clearly a step behind. PDA White on the other hand has some pretty poor showings.

          Comment


            Originally posted by Guest View Post

            PDA south lost to SJEB 2-0, MFA 3-2, and PDA Blue 3-0. Those are not bad games, just clearly a step behind. PDA White on the other hand has some pretty poor showings.
            And PDA south is 9 out of 11 in NA ECNL conf. The only team they beat is PDA white. Let's assume the SJEB top player ( who is very good BTW) decides to go to PDA blue... how would SJEB fair then if they moved to ECNL? like another bottom of the barrel team.

            Ukies moved from GA ( completely overhauled their roster) and I think their best team right now is in 7th.

            the ECNL doesn't need more terrible teams. I have said this before ( and it is reflective of my own daughters journey) - there are not enough girl athletes in general to support the growth of the NL or RL leagues.

            Comment


              Originally posted by Guest View Post

              And PDA south is 9 out of 11 in NA ECNL conf. The only team they beat is PDA white. Let's assume the SJEB top player ( who is very good BTW) decides to go to PDA blue... how would SJEB fair then if they moved to ECNL? like another bottom of the barrel team.

              Ukies moved from GA ( completely overhauled their roster) and I think their best team right now is in 7th.

              the ECNL doesn't need more terrible teams. I have said this before ( and it is reflective of my own daughters journey) - there are not enough girl athletes in general to support the growth of the NL or RL leagues.
              your last statement is spot on. Not everyone who plays in these leagues especially RL is an elite player.

              Comment


                Originally posted by Guest View Post
                I’m sure PDA south or pda white would take many of the Mercer girls in a heartbeat. But those two teams may be too far. DO NOT LEAVE YOUR RL TEAM FOR ANOTHER RL TEAM. That would be pointless.
                Although our record doesnt show, South is close and just missing a few pieces. This move for be great for everyone, other than MF Mercer.

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Guest View Post

                  Although our record doesnt show, South is close and just missing a few pieces. This move for be great for everyone, other than MF Mercer.
                  I agree. If pda south gets a few of MFA Mercer top players.. that just makes pda south stronger.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Guest View Post

                    This is all the leagues. GA/ECNL/RL, MFA just beat Hex 8-0? It'd be great if we just let the top 8 teams in NJ play each other in a league, PDA, FA, SJEB, MFA, Real, CSA, Mercer, PDA South. Good games every week.
                    Makes too much sense. Will never happen.

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Guest View Post

                      Makes too much sense. Will never happen.
                      These leagues are bs. Many good teams much better than hex in local leagues.

                      Comment


                        Originally posted by Guest View Post

                        Most? Lol stop ir. Maybe younger like 2015-2012. Stops there.
                        This is the point they are making. Take away the badge and make it an even playing field like it is until u13, PDA wouldn’t be near these clubs. It has shown, they get better because of a badge, not because of coaching or the quality of their program. The two clubs mentioned above are ahead when it comes to coaching quality, program infrastructure and player development. Just another reminder to us parents how our soccer system robs everyone of equal competition!

                        Comment


                          Originally posted by Guest View Post

                          And PDA south is 9 out of 11 in NA ECNL conf. The only team they beat is PDA white. Let's assume the SJEB top player ( who is very good BTW) decides to go to PDA blue... how would SJEB fair then if they moved to ECNL? like another bottom of the barrel team.

                          Ukies moved from GA ( completely overhauled their roster) and I think their best team right now is in 7th.

                          the ECNL doesn't need more terrible teams. I have said this before ( and it is reflective of my own daughters journey) - there are not enough girl athletes in general to support the growth of the NL or RL leagues.
                          Teams like SJEB aren’t just built around 1, 2 or even 3 players. They are very balanced from top to bottom and would do extremely well in ENCL. While they’ were all close games and some have picked up new players, they have beaten MFA, PDA Blue, and South all in just the last 6 months. It’s all there for you to see.

                          Comment


                            Originally posted by Guest View Post

                            Although our record doesnt show, South is close and just missing a few pieces. This move for be great for everyone, other than MF Mercer.
                            South isn’t close to anything. Their only hope is to poach.

                            Being at the top of a GA conference and making the playoffs every year will give you more visibility than being a mid/bottom ECNL team. You can’t dispute that.

                            Not worth moving to an inferior club/team.

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Guest View Post

                              Teams like SJEB aren’t just built around 1, 2 or even 3 players. They are very balanced from top to bottom and would do extremely well in ENCL. While they’ were all close games and some have picked up new players, they have beaten MFA, PDA Blue, and South all in just the last 6 months. It’s all there for you to see.
                              Only one was noticeable to me. Sorry.

                              Comment


                                Originally posted by Guest View Post

                                South isn’t close to anything. Their only hope is to poach.

                                Being at the top of a GA conference and making the playoffs every year will give you more visibility than being a mid/bottom ECNL team. You can’t dispute that.

                                Not worth moving to an inferior club/team.
                                Mercer is not GA. They are ECRL.

                                Comment

                                Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                                Auto-Saved
                                x
                                Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                                x
                                Working...
                                X