Originally posted by Guest
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
2011 Girls Rankings
Collapse
X
-
Guest
- Quote
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
You would have to look at past tournaments to compare similar competition. Cant blame the league they are put in, but if they dominate the league then rankings are justified, team just above competition. Examples are MF Shore ECRL and NJ Premier NAL. One could argue PDA Blue above MF North because of ECNL standings but MF beats them head to head continually so they are better. PDA White and South could compete in this top 10 but they are just too inconsistent and will likely fall further as they are becoming less and less of a draw. The difference in all these teams is 2-3 players that is all.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
Yeh putting nj premier- playing in a tier 4 league- above pdas is nonsense , same with mercer, playing in a tier 3 league. The Stas, csa, sjebs can do similar in ecnl to what pda south/ white are doing with minimal variance
unless the ECNL team losing every game plays the 3rd tier team that wins every game by 6 goals, how can you really compare?
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
agreed, but what can you say about a team in a 3rd or 4th tier league when they win every game 6-0 (not saying they are, just an example). No promotions/delegations so no compare.
unless the ECNL team losing every game plays the 3rd tier team that wins every game by 6 goals, how can you really compare?
MF Shore 9-0-0 GD 36
PDA Blue 6-1-4 GD 14
MF North 5-2-4 GD 13
SJEB 4-3-1 GD 11
RealNJ 4-2-1 GD 10
NJ Premier 7-0-0 GD 39
MF Mercer 7-1-2 GD GD 11
Marlton Chiefs 5-1-4 GD 7
STA GA 5-3-2 GD 9
CSA M GA 6-3-1 GD 17
Way to much free time.
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post5 teams fighting for those 3 ecnl playoff spots... it's going to be close. .
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
agreed, but what can you say about a team in a 3rd or 4th tier league when they win every game 6-0 (not saying they are, just an example). No promotions/delegations so no compare.
unless the ECNL team losing every game plays the 3rd tier team that wins every game by 6 goals, how can you really compare?
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View Post
Fair point but playing in a tier 4 league is just much easier, very hard to take a morsel of that as meaningful. I'll agree on mf shore, better league and complete domination and some decent history vs teams outside of ecrl2. Guess we'll see where Premier is as they face off with shore this weekend
Good to see teams in lower leagues playing each other this weekend
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Originally posted by Guest View PostSpring Preseason 2011 Top 10 Rankings:
1. MF North
2. PDA Blue
3. SJEB GA
4. REALNJ GA
5. MFA Shore
6. CSA Monmouth GA
7. MFA Mercer
8. Marlton Chiefs
9. NJ Premier
10. STA GA
In the hunt:
Jersey Shore Boca, PDA South, PDA White,
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
-
Guest
Not making excuses, just wondering, are tournaments this time of year a good way to gauge teams? Do they all have their best players?
- Quote
Comment
-
Guest
Comment