Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Club Commitment List Accuracy Analysis

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
    It isn't affiliated with the ECNL. Extra training for the top players in the club with a couple of extra events.
    How is the debt repayment going? That's a big nut in bethany

    Comment


      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
      How is the debt repayment going? That's a big nut in bethany
      Great! Just like the soccer

      Comment


        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
        How is the debt repayment going? That's a big nut in bethany
        How's FSAs? Or OW's? All of their infrastructure doesn't come cheap either. I give CFC credit for getting it done without begging families for money

        not with CFC

        Comment


          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
          2017 Backup Data –

          YU 8 of 18 not on a roster = 44% false
          FS 4/16 = 25% false
          OW 2/15 = 13% false
          CFC 1/32 = 3% false

          Here’s the 2017 ECNL commit list…

          https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...uO1GI/htmlview

          Here’s the Oakwood Commitment List, which includes every class year mixed together…
          https://www.oakwoodsoccer.com/college-commitments

          …and here’s the OW official roster used to cross reference to ascertain which were 2017 grads…
          http://home.gotsoccer.com/rankings/t...y=yes&compact=

          Here’s the 2017 Yankee list…
          http://yankeeunited.com/Page.asp?n=1...NKEEUNITED.COM
          ^^^^ let the buyer beware!

          Comment


            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
            ^^^^ let the buyer beware!
            ^^^^^^^ super helpful comment!

            Comment


              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
              For this year, here’s the link to the 2018 ECNL Commitments….

              https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets...uV0/edit#gid=0
              Here’s the GDA lists

              http://www.ussoccerda.com/20180208-n...-for-fall-2018

              Comment


                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                ^^^^^^^ super helpful comment!
                Actually it is. Parents new to the higher level leagues are easily fooled by commitment lists. Lists aren't entirely reflective of development but are one indicator of what college coaches think of players from those clubs. Players who are supposedly recruited but aren't actually on rosters - mistakes by the clubs or outright dishonesty? Good for parents to know. Same with whether or not players actually are playing in college. Many are not by junior year no matter where they trained. It's the harsh reality of college soccer. Good for parents to keep that in perspective also

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                  Actually it is. Parents new to the higher level leagues are easily fooled by commitment lists. Lists aren't entirely reflective of development but are one indicator of what college coaches think of players from those clubs. Players who are supposedly recruited but aren't actually on rosters - mistakes by the clubs or outright dishonesty? Good for parents to know. Same with whether or not players actually are playing in college. Many are not by junior year no matter where they trained. It's the harsh reality of college soccer. Good for parents to keep that in perspective also
                  It's not just the top clubs. This verification makes sense if you are looking at medium and smaller clubs as well (If some type of college play is desired by your child). My daughter moved from a medium sized club to a large one few years ago. I looked at this for the club she left and a few other local clubs. You can tell which clubs are honest and which are not.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                    It’s actually the DA list (boys and girls), not strictly the GDA list.

                    Quickly looked at both the ECNL girls only list and the DA (boys and girls) list.

                    DA total clubs submitting - 94
                    DA total commitments - 1,056

                    ECNL girls clubs submitting - 79
                    ECNL girls commitments - 1,161

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                      It’s actually the DA list (boys and girls), not strictly the GDA list.

                      Quickly looked at both the ECNL girls only list and the DA (boys and girls) list.

                      DA total clubs submitting - 94
                      DA total commitments - 1,056

                      ECNL girls clubs submitting - 79
                      ECNL girls commitments - 1,161
                      There's well over 20,000 D1, D2 and D3 college roster spots out there, plus all the others. The top 2 leagues won't fill all the spots out there, just like they didn't before GDA. http://scholarshipstats.com/soccer.html

                      Comment


                        Ready for the 2018 update

                        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                        Final 2017 Accuracy % -

                        YU - 56%
                        FSA - 75%
                        OW - 87%
                        CFC - 97%

                        2017 Single Season College Soccer Quality Analysis

                        As determined by % of schools on commit list that made the NCAA postseason (in D1, D2, or D3) for Fall 2017. To remain objective we are looking only at whether that college was considered in the top 64 schools (top 48 for D2) for that single season.

                        YU – 0 of 16 = 0%
                        OW – 2 of 14 = 14%
                        FSA – 2 of 13 = 15%
                        CFC – 8 of 28 = 29%
                        Let’s go! Update already!

                        Comment


                          Only .5% of all female high school aged players play GDA or ECNL. If you play there, and want to play in college, you will. The rest of the leagues will have to fight it out for what's left.

                          Comment


                            This "analysis" is basically an assessment of the placement ratio for the last club a given child played for. There are a number of kids on the FSA commitment list that spent many many years at other clubs. Ditto CFC and Yankee. Kids move around. The value of the list is kind of meaningless unless you assume it to measure the given "sway" a given club has in getting college coaches to look at your kid.

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                              This "analysis" is basically an assessment of the placement ratio for the last club a given child played for. There are a number of kids on the FSA commitment list that spent many many years at other clubs. Ditto CFC and Yankee. Kids move around. The value of the list is kind of meaningless unless you assume it to measure the given "sway" a given club has in getting college coaches to look at your kid.
                              What the list shows is documented. Yankee was proven to provide fake news. Fsa talks a good game but in the end has a very poor commit class year in and year out. Oakwood is a half step up on Fsa, but if youcompare vs what they claim, ie number one development club and the best league where all future national pool players will come from, you can see how full of Krap they are. Last but not least...cfcu is the winner year in and year out on placements

                              Comment


                                Still waiting on some D3 rosters to post 2018 players....but there is already some spurious listings from our favorite commitment list fabricators...

                                Comment

                                Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                                Auto-Saved
                                x
                                Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                                x
                                Working...
                                X