Originally posted by Unregistered
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Worst coach at FSA
Collapse
X
-
Unregistered
- Quote
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostSounds like our town travel tryouts. And they do not make the results public even to the parents of each kid. Its because the third party evaluators dont know the kids and suck. The player rankings are ridiculous. These are used to try to placate the masses but it pisses them iff more in our town because the results are never even close to right and can not be used to justify anything. Even more annoying is that the teams of the board members come out just like they wanted them which is usually the exact same as last season. If you are going to do valid rankings and scoring make them available to the parents. Hi-lite their kid and mask the names of all of the others to show them how their kid fared vs their peers which shows sttengths and things they need to work on. And make sure when the rosters come out that the board members kid who can walk and chew gum isnt in the A roster ahead of a decent little player that needs some work (which also always happens ..... Its why everyone in our town gets involved on boards ..... So they can get their kids onto A teams).
Our town club did assessments internally and it was fraught with politics and who you know type decisions in spite of the assessors being other coaches in the org. Coaches could basically override the assessor decisions so in the end it was really a waste of everyones time for a lot of teams. if you bring in independent assessors, I would think it would be better unless you have 5 assessors trying to assess 400 kids on 20 teams in 4 nights in which case it might be a crapshoot. But I do not think theres a foolproof way of doing it without a kid somewhere falling through the cracks or being assessed inappropriately.
Replace the parent coaches with credentialed coaches leading some of these organizations and I think you have a much better system (but fees go up a few hundred each year).
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostNow you realize it does not matter whether little Johnny is ranked #4 or #6 or #8 on the team as they will all make the team. You release results to the parents and it is going to matter whether Johnny is ranked #4 or #6 or #8. Why create drama by releasing stuff like that.
Our town club did assessments internally and it was fraught with politics and who you know type decisions in spite of the assessors being other coaches in the org. Coaches could basically override the assessor decisions so in the end it was really a waste of everyones time for a lot of teams. if you bring in independent assessors, I would think it would be better unless you have 5 assessors trying to assess 400 kids on 20 teams in 4 nights in which case it might be a crapshoot. But I do not think theres a foolproof way of doing it without a kid somewhere falling through the cracks or being assessed inappropriately.
Replace the parent coaches with credentialed coaches leading some of these organizations and I think you have a much better system (but fees go up a few hundred each year).
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostIf you can't justify them and are afraid to publish them then they probably arent worth the time and effort no one put into them.
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
Originally posted by Unregistered View PostAre everyone's annual reviews and salary and/or bonus decisions at your place of employment published so everyone can review them?
- Quote
Comment
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
-
Unregistered
Comment