Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Problem With Over Coaching From The Sideline

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    The Problem With Over Coaching From The Sideline

    http://www.theawayendfooty.com/the-h...m-the-sideline

    #2
    If I don't instruct my daughter from the sidelines how will she know what to do?

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
      If I don't instruct my daughter from the sidelines how will she know what to do?
      Gosh it took less that 1 hour for you to find, read and respond to this with the classic Yuck Tuck like you're a comedic genius for pulling that rabbit out of the hat. You must be a real hoot around the water cooler at work.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
        Gosh it took less that 1 hour for you to find, read and respond to this with the classic Yuck Tuck like you're a comedic genius for pulling that rabbit out of the hat. You must be a real hoot around the water cooler at work.
        I actually think that's how many of us think. Maybe you should lighten up a bit Francis.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
          Gosh it took less that 1 hour for you to find, read and respond to this with the classic Yuck Tuck like you're a comedic genius for pulling that rabbit out of the hat. You must be a real hoot around the water cooler at work.
          Hey Gomer. I don't think someone was trying to be funny. I will type real slow for you so you can follow. Many, many parents, especially at younger ages, think they need to coach their kids from the sidelines. Go to a U9 girls game. Or U10 boys game. Non stop.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
            Hey Gomer. I don't think someone was trying to be funny. I will type real slow for you so you can follow. Many, many parents, especially at younger ages, think they need to coach their kids from the sidelines. Go to a U9 girls game. Or U10 boys game. Non stop.
            And some parents still don't get even by high school. The problem is parents who coach too much, or helicopter a lot in general, tend to be (any or in combination)

            - insecure about their kids' abilities
            - frightened of their kids' failing because it will "hurt their feelings"
            - frightened of their kids' feelings because they think it's a reflection on them as parents

            they also -

            - often don't know they're doing it
            - even if they do, they think there's nothing wrong with it

            So posting an article about it isn't going to get them to change. It usually takes either someone pointing it out to them, their kids firing back at them (stop embarrassing me!) or some other embarrassing incident.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
              And some parents still don't get even by high school. The problem is parents who coach too much, or helicopter a lot in general, tend to be (any or in combination)

              - insecure about their kids' abilities
              - frightened of their kids' failing because it will "hurt their feelings"
              - frightened of their kids' feelings because they think it's a reflection on them as parents

              they also -

              - often don't know they're doing it
              - even if they do, they think there's nothing wrong with it

              So posting an article about it isn't going to get them to change. It usually takes either someone pointing it out to them, their kids firing back at them (stop embarrassing me!) or some other embarrassing incident.
              Here's a thought...who cares? Soccer is dumb.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                And some parents still don't get even by high school. The problem is parents who coach too much, or helicopter a lot in general, tend to be (any or in combination)

                - insecure about their kids' abilities
                - frightened of their kids' failing because it will "hurt their feelings"
                - frightened of their kids' feelings because they think it's a reflection on them as parents

                they also -

                - often don't know they're doing it
                - even if they do, they think there's nothing wrong with it

                So posting an article about it isn't going to get them to change. It usually takes either someone pointing it out to them, their kids firing back at them (stop embarrassing me!) or some other embarrassing incident.
                Heard about coaches that will bench a player if a parent tries coaching them or others from the sideline. That stops it really quickly. We have a couple parents that sideline coach at u16. All the team hates it. Then there are the parents that yell "great job!" even when it was far from a great job.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                  Then there are the parents that yell "great job!" even when it was far from a great job.
                  Might be the only positive thing your dd hears all game. Even if it's from you.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                    Might be the only positive thing your dd hears all game. Even if it's from you.
                    You just couldn't resist being a dick, could you?

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                      Here's a thought...who cares? Soccer is dumb.
                      So you're posting on a soccer forum because....?

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                        And some parents still don't get even by high school. The problem is parents who coach too much, or helicopter a lot in general, tend to be (any or in combination)

                        - insecure about their kids' abilities
                        - frightened of their kids' failing because it will "hurt their feelings"
                        - frightened of their kids' feelings because they think it's a reflection on them as parents

                        they also -

                        - often don't know they're doing it
                        - even if they do, they think there's nothing wrong with it

                        So posting an article about it isn't going to get them to change. It usually takes either someone pointing it out to them, their kids firing back at them (stop embarrassing me!) or some other embarrassing incident.
                        The article isn't really about parent coaching ... it actually focuses on over-coaching done on the sideline by the coaches themselves. "Joysticking" the players if you will and creating little drones who are lost when not being commanded by their coach.

                        Good article and goes a long way to explain why the US doesn't develop great creative attacking players who can problem solve on the fly.

                        Parent coaching from the sideline is another issue entirely and should be squashed by the coach before the season even begins.

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                          The article isn't really about parent coaching ... it actually focuses on over-coaching done on the sideline by the coaches themselves. "Joysticking" the players if you will and creating little drones who are lost when not being commanded by their coach.

                          Good article and goes a long way to explain why the US doesn't develop great creative attacking players who can problem solve on the fly.

                          Parent coaching from the sideline is another issue entirely and should be squashed by the coach before the season even begins.
                          As a coach it's finding the right balance of instruction during games. Players need to make decisions on their own, make mistakes so they learn from it. My son had a great coach for a year who coached them with questions such as "Can we find the angle to support him?

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                            The article isn't really about parent coaching ... it actually focuses on over-coaching done on the sideline by the coaches themselves. "Joysticking" the players if you will and creating little drones who are lost when not being commanded by their coach.
                            .
                            My D had one of those at club and son at HS. Both learned to tune them out and do their thing :) Not all players can do that though, especially the younger ones

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                              So you're posting on a soccer forum because....?
                              Trolls gotta troll. Plus with the anonymity, and this sites propensity to take all subjects into the gutter, it's a great place to practice your trolling before going out into the real world.

                              Comment

                              Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                              Auto-Saved
                              x
                              Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                              x
                              Working...
                              X