Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Bigger forces than local clubs and parents, root cause

Collapse
X
  •  
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Bigger forces than local clubs and parents, root cause

    The MLS mandated the Portland Timbers to have a full compliment of "Academy" youth teams. In the decision making process of how to implement this directive, the Timbers brass decided to make it a local feeder program vs the option of having it based elsewhere like a similar sized MLS franchise located in the Western States Real Salt Lake, who opted to base their Academy in Arizona and recruit nationally in their effort to attract potential MLS or professional level players. The end product the MLS is striving for is 'Home Grown' players whose MLS wages are at the bottom of the MLS salary structure. Creating value/profits if a homegrown player can be sold to a world power like the EPL for top dollar. MLS selling players like Deandre Yedlin to Tottenham produces massive profit for the league and it's member club, seattle sounders. Yedlin was sold for a reported 4million dollars 75% which could go to the club directly per MLS guidelines. This type of model in the Portland market is questionable at best.

    Why the ECNL decided to allocate two league spots to the Portland market to the local non-profit soccer clubs is quite head scratching given the documented talent of players and coaches available.

    #2
    When your eyes are bigger than your stomach, this is what happens.

    Comment


      #3
      Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
      The MLS mandated the Portland Timbers to have a full compliment of "Academy" youth teams. In the decision making process of how to implement this directive, the Timbers brass decided to make it a local feeder program vs the option of having it based elsewhere like a similar sized MLS franchise located in the Western States Real Salt Lake, who opted to base their Academy in Arizona and recruit nationally in their effort to attract potential MLS or professional level players. The end product the MLS is striving for is 'Home Grown' players whose MLS wages are at the bottom of the MLS salary structure. Creating value/profits if a homegrown player can be sold to a world power like the EPL for top dollar. MLS selling players like Deandre Yedlin to Tottenham produces massive profit for the league and it's member club, seattle sounders. Yedlin was sold for a reported 4million dollars 75% which could go to the club directly per MLS guidelines. This type of model in the Portland market is questionable at best.

      Why the ECNL decided to allocate two league spots to the Portland market to the local non-profit soccer clubs is quite head scratching given the documented talent of players and coaches available.
      Very well said. I agree. How do parents, or the silent majority change the absurd direction that our youth's sports are heading? It is all about money.

      Comment


        #4
        Options are good. Choose one or the other ECNL club, or none, as you see fit.

        Comment


          #5
          Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
          Very well said. I agree. How do parents, or the silent majority change the absurd direction that our youth's sports are heading? It is all about money.
          How you do it is to keep all our kids in rec soccer.

          Comment


            #6
            Excellent

            Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
            How you do it is to keep all our kids in rec soccer.
            The culture and landscape of Oregon Youth Club soccer is being kept at a Rec level, very well said.

            Slapping acronyms, new club nicknames or MLS franchise monikers maintains the rec culture hidden behind the paper thin labels of ECNL, Crossfire or TIMBERS.

            Keep it Generic Portland! But please give it a name that sounds better than it is.
            and make sure the help gets paid very well. What's the problem?
            asks the local DOC with the 6 figure salary running the local community non-profit Soccer club.

            This same trend happened in the Real Estate market 'bubble' a few years back.

            Too Big to Fail :)

            Comment


              #7
              Parents can help by becoming informed, serving as a board member of your child's club, volunteer as a parent-coach or manager . . . all those pieces help. If you are OYSA club, become a member of their board. Let your voice be heard.

              I don't think the Timbers instituting a (mostly free) academy or having 2 ECNL teams in this market are inherently bad thing . . . losing players to those forces is to be expected and not unhealthy, although it wouldn't be the worse thing in the world to see healthy local competition to all of those. I also don't think the Timbers Alliance is necessarily a problem as a commercial deal; I view it more negatively now than I did 18 months ago as it started look more like a political coalition.

              I do think the interests of the Timbers and ECNL have polluted the local league(s) landscape, at least in the short-term.
              Last edited by Slow Xavi; 05-19-2015, 07:24 PM.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Slow Xavi View Post
                Parents can help by becoming informed, serving as a board member of your child's club, volunteer as a parent-coach or manager . . . all those pieces help. If you are OYSA club, become a member of their board. Let your voice be heard.

                I don't think the Timbers instituting a (mostly free) academy or having 2 ECNL teams in this market are inherently bad thing . . . losing players to those forces is to be expected and not unhealthy, although it wouldn't be the worse thing in the world to see healthy local competition to all of those. I also don't think the Timbers Alliance is necessarily a problem as a commercial deal; I view it more negatively now than I did 18 months ago as it started look more like a political coalition.

                I do think the interests of the Timbers and ECNL have polluted the local league(s) landscape, at least in the short-term.
                The reality is these non-profit clubs are community based clubs structured to be lead by local parents/volunteers trusted to serve the mission of the club and the neighborhoods where they practice and play games. About 10-15 years ago Volunteer boards couldn't handle the work load associated with managing their growing recreational and classic club. They shifted the workload to paid coaching directors, operation directors, camp directors, clinic directors, age group coaches, goalkeeper coaches, tournament directors and nowadays the 'board' is merely a lame dame entity and the ambtions of a President & DOC dictate policy and have defacto control of the club. "absolute power corrupts absolutely"

                No oversight or accountability.

                Now you have been informed, as you mention above. What next?

                Comment


                  #9
                  Originally posted by Unregistered View Post
                  How you do it is to keep all our kids in rec soccer.
                  I remember when kids played sports in school and on the dirt lot in the neighborhood.
                  Politics and money then were whether you were hitting on someone else's girlfriend and if you had a buck for candy.

                  Comment

                  Previously entered content was automatically saved. Restore or Discard.
                  Auto-Saved
                  x
                  Insert: Thumbnail Small Medium Large Fullsize Remove  
                  x
                  Working...
                  X